JOIN THE RACE

Sign in to save scores, appear on leaderboards and track personal bests.

Home› Automobile Receipts› Rivian R1T vs Tesla Model 3

Rivian R1T VS Tesla Model 3

Rivian R1T Tesla Model 3
Verdict BUY IT DROP IT
The Reality NHTSA lists 7 recalls for the 2023 R1T, more than most competitors on this list by count -- but the substance is notably mild: a software bug that could deactivate the defroster, improperly aimed headlights, a mis-labeled tire placard, and several fastener/bolt-torque issues found during service (seat belt anchorage bolts, a suspension toe link, seat belt retractor bolts). None involve the fire-risk battery defects seen on several competing EVs in this same batch of entries. NHTSA's complaint database shows 38 complaints for the 2023 R1T -- one of the lower counts among the vehicles checked. A Reuters investigation (reported by Electrek) found Tesla's comparison methodology inflates the safety claim by roughly 3x — Tesla counts only crashes severe enough to deploy an airbag in its own data, then compares that to NHTSA/FHWA federal data that includes all crashes requiring a tow truck, a far lower severity threshold. Separately, NHTSA's own complaint database shows 420 real complaints filed against the 2023 Model 3 alone, dominated by Forward Collision Avoidance issues (131+ complaints combining several sub-categories) and Steering (52) — including multiple specific, dated reports of 'phantom braking' (the car braking hard for no obstacle) and at least two separate documented incidents of the vehicle running a red light while on Autopilot/FSD, one of which caused an accident. Tesla's Model 3 has also had 12 NHTSA recalls in 2023, 5 in 2024, 3 in 2025, and 1 so far in 2026 (most recently a seat-fastener issue, unrelated to Autopilot).
SHORT ANSWER

Rivian R1T: Rivian's R1T capability and performance claims are independently verified accurate, and NHTSA's recall data backs up the positive reputation -- all 7 recalls are software or fastener issues, with no fire-risk battery defects like several competing EVs have had.

Tesla Model 3: Tesla's claim that Autopilot/FSD is 'up to 10x safer' than human drivers is disputed by an independent Reuters investigation, which found the comparison methodology inflates the figure roughly 3x — and NHTSA's own complaint database shows 420 real complaints on the 2023 Model 3 alone, dominated by phantom-braking and collision-avoidance issues.