JOIN THE RACE

Sign in to save scores, appear on leaderboards and track personal bests.

Home› Automobile Receipts› Jeep Wrangler 4xe vs Honda Civic

Jeep Wrangler 4xe VS Honda Civic

Jeep Wrangler 4xe Honda Civic
Verdict DROP IT BUY IT
The Reality The 49 MPGe figure is a real EPA rating, but MPGe is a different unit than MPG -- it converts electric-motor efficiency into a gasoline-equivalent number, and once the plug-in hybrid's battery is depleted, the 4xe reverts to running on its gas engine at the same roughly 20 MPG combined as a non-hybrid Wrangler. Separately, and more seriously, NHTSA's recall database lists 14 recalls for the 2023 Wrangler 4xe, including two labeled as a genuine vehicle fire risk: 'the high voltage battery may fail internally and lead to a vehicle fire while parked or driving.' A third recall covers an engine that can shut down mid-drive due to a communication loss, and a fourth covers incorrect fasteners on the battery's 200-amp fuse that can generate excessive heat. NHTSA's complaint database shows 342 complaints for the 2023 model year -- the second-highest of any vehicle checked in this comparison. IIHS's own published ratings show the 2023 Civic sedan and hatchback actually earned the plain 'Top Safety Pick' award, one tier below 'Top Safety Pick+' -- the 2022 model year Civic held the higher TSP+ rating, but IIHS's criteria change annually and the 2023 model didn't requalify at that tier. Separately, NHTSA's recall database lists 4 recalls for the 2023 Civic, all shared-platform issues rather than Civic-specific defects: a brake fluid leak in the stability-assist module (shared with the Acura RDX, Integra, and Accord), a steering rack that may have been incorrectly reassembled during a prior service repair, a broader steering defect affecting multiple Honda/Acura models, and a driver's seat cushion fastener issue. NHTSA's complaint database shows 0 complaints filed for the 2023 Civic.
SHORT ANSWER

Jeep Wrangler 4xe: The Wrangler 4xe's 49 MPGe rating is real but only applies with regular charging -- on gas alone it matches a non-hybrid Wrangler's ~20 MPG -- and NHTSA has recalled its plug-in hybrid battery twice for a genuine vehicle-fire risk.

Honda Civic: The 2023 Honda Civic actually earned IIHS's plain 'Top Safety Pick' award, not the higher 'Top Safety Pick+' tier some dealer sites advertise -- but its real recall and complaint record is clean: 4 shared-platform recalls and zero owner complaints on file.