JOIN THE RACE

Sign in to save scores, appear on leaderboards and track personal bests.

Home› Food Receipts› Activia Yogurt vs Cheerios

Activia Yogurt VS Cheerios

Activia Yogurt Cheerios
Verdict DROP IT BUY IT
The Reality The FTC's investigation, conducted jointly with 39 state Attorneys General, found that 8 of the 10 scientific studies Dannon relied on actually showed no statistically significant effect of Activia on digestive transit time compared to a placebo. Dannon settled with the FTC in 2011, agreeing to stop using the specific words 'clinically' and 'scientifically proven' in favor of softer language like 'clinical studies show,' and to stop claiming any cold- or flu-prevention benefit unless the FDA approved that specific message. Separately, a parallel consumer class action resulted in Dannon paying up to $45 million in damages, and the FTC settlement included a simultaneous $21 million settlement with the 39 states. On May 5, 2009, the FDA sent General Mills a formal warning letter finding these specific, quantified claims made Cheerios an unapproved new drug under federal law, since companies are legally barred from quantifying a specific percentage health benefit the way General Mills had. Critically, the underlying science itself wasn't in dispute: Cheerios' general soluble-fiber cholesterol-lowering claim had already been an FDA-authorized qualified health claim for 12 years at that point, and General Mills maintained the clinical study behind the 4% figure was genuinely strong. The issue the FDA flagged was specifically the precise quantification ('4% in 6 weeks'), not the broader, already-approved claim that whole-grain oat soluble fiber can help reduce cholesterol as part of a diet low in saturated fat.
SHORT ANSWER

Activia Yogurt: The FTC's investigation, joined by 39 state Attorneys General, found 8 of 10 studies Dannon cited for Activia's 'clinically proven' digestive claims showed no significant effect versus a placebo, resulting in a 2011 settlement and a separate $45 million consumer class-action payout.

Cheerios: Cheerios' general claim that whole-grain oat soluble fiber can help lower cholesterol is a legitimate, FDA-authorized health claim with real science behind it -- but General Mills' specific 2009 quantified claim ('4% in 6 weeks') crossed into illegal, unapproved drug-claim territory and drew a formal FDA warning letter.